AP Comparative Government and Politics Reading and Writing Workshop
Reading and Writing Workshop: Political Institutions and Participation
Objective: Students will analyze political institutions and participation using public domain works to develop a deeper understanding of the structures and processes that shape governance across different political systems. The workshop will include guided reading, discussion, and written responses in the form of SAQs and FRQs.
Materials:
Part One: Reading and Analysis
Students will read excerpts from the provided texts, focusing on the following themes:
Part Two: Writing Workshop (SAQs and FRQs)
Students will apply their readings to answer SAQs and FRQs in preparation for the AP Comparative Government and Politics exam.
SAQs:
Assessment and Discussion:
Objective: Students will analyze political institutions and participation using public domain works to develop a deeper understanding of the structures and processes that shape governance across different political systems. The workshop will include guided reading, discussion, and written responses in the form of SAQs and FRQs.
Materials:
- The Federalist Papers (No. 10 and No. 51) by James Madison
- The Spirit of the Laws by Montesquieu (excerpts on separation of powers)
- Democracy in America by Alexis de Tocqueville (excerpts on civil society and participation)
- John Stuart Mill’s Considerations on Representative Government (excerpts on democratic institutions)
Part One: Reading and Analysis
Students will read excerpts from the provided texts, focusing on the following themes:
- Political Institutions: Structure of government, separation of powers, rule of law
- Participation: Civil society, political culture, electoral systems, legitimacy
- How does Madison justify the need for checks and balances in Federalist No. 51
- What does Montesquieu argue is the ideal structure for a government to prevent tyranny
- According to Tocqueville, what role does civil society play in maintaining a democratic system
- How does John Stuart Mill define the strengths and weaknesses of representative democracy
Part Two: Writing Workshop (SAQs and FRQs)
Students will apply their readings to answer SAQs and FRQs in preparation for the AP Comparative Government and Politics exam.
SAQs:
- Explain one way in which the concept of separation of powers strengthens democratic institutions according to Montesquieu.
- Identify and explain one argument made by Madison in Federalist No. 10 regarding factions and their impact on democratic governance.
- Describe one way in which Tocqueville’s analysis of civil society applies to a contemporary political system.
- Compare one aspect of Mill’s argument about representative government with a modern political system.
- Conceptual Analysis: Using the works of Madison, Montesquieu, and Mill, analyze how different political institutions manage political participation and maintain legitimacy.
- Comparative Analysis: Compare the role of civil society in two political systems, drawing on Tocqueville’s analysis and a modern example.
- Application: Discuss how the principles of separation of powers and checks and balances have been implemented differently in presidential and parliamentary systems, using examples from at least two countries.
- Argumentative Essay: Based on the readings, construct an argument that evaluates the effectiveness of representative democracy in ensuring broad political participation.
Assessment and Discussion:
- Peer review and discussion of SAQ responses
- Group debates on the strengths and weaknesses of different political institutions
- Teacher-led discussion connecting historical perspectives to modern governance