All My Sons by Arthur Miller tells the story of a munitions factory owner who is accused of producing defective engines for aircraft leading to serious family complications.
All My Sons by Arthur Miller
Workshop Overview
This workshop engages students in collaborative reading, dramatic performance, ethical debate, and analytical writing centered on All My Sons, a post–World War II tragedy exploring family, responsibility, and moral integrity.
Students will:
Essential Questions
Core Themes (Student Anchor)
WORKSHOP STRUCTURE
SESSION 1: ENTRY EVENT – THE CRASH INVESTIGATION
Student Handouts
Experiential Hook (Simulation)
Students enter as investigators examining a wartime disaster:
Each group receives:
“Today, you are not students—you are investigators. A tragedy has occurred, and your job is to determine responsibility. But be warned: in this case, truth is not simple.”
SESSION 2: CONTEXT + FIRST READING (ACT I)
Mini-Lesson
Assign roles:
“Is Joe Keller a good man? Why or why not?”
SESSION 3: CHARACTER ON TRIAL (ACT II)
Experiential Activity: Mock Trial
Each group represents:
Students use:
“You are about to decide whether Joe Keller is simply a father protecting his family—or a man responsible for the deaths of others.”
SESSION 4: REVEAL & MORAL COLLAPSE (ACT III)
Reading Focus
Joe’s actions reflect a failure to recognize responsibility beyond his family, leading to devastating consequences (SparkNotes).
SESSION 5: ETHICAL DEBATE – FAMILY VS. SOCIETY
Structured Debate
Prompt:
“Is a person’s first responsibility to their family or to society?”
Positions
Connect to:
SESSION 6: WRITING WORKSHOP – ARGUMENT + SYNTHESIS
Writing Prompt Options
“Your job is not to retell the story—it is to make an argument about what the story means.”
SESSION 7: CREATIVE PERFORMANCE TASK
Option A: Scene Rewrites
Students rewrite a key scene:
Set the story in:
Groups perform their revised scenes.
SESSION 8: SOCRATIC SEMINAR
Discussion Questions
SESSION 9: FINAL PERFORMANCE TASK – “ALL MY SONS” PROJECT
Group Project Options
Option 1: Documentary
ASSESSMENT
Formative
RUBRIC (Simplified)
Reading & Analysis
OPTIONAL EXTENSIONS
TEACHER NOTES
Workshop Overview
This workshop engages students in collaborative reading, dramatic performance, ethical debate, and analytical writing centered on All My Sons, a post–World War II tragedy exploring family, responsibility, and moral integrity.
Students will:
- Analyze character motivations and ethical dilemmas
- Evaluate themes of guilt, responsibility, and the American Dream
- Engage in experiential simulations and performance-based learning
- Develop argumentative and synthesis writing skills
Essential Questions
- What do we owe to others beyond our family?
- Can personal success justify immoral actions?
- Who is responsible for the consequences of our choices?
Core Themes (Student Anchor)
- Family vs. Social Responsibility
- Guilt and Accountability
- The Corruption of the American Dream
- Truth vs. Denial
WORKSHOP STRUCTURE
SESSION 1: ENTRY EVENT – THE CRASH INVESTIGATION
Student Handouts
Experiential Hook (Simulation)
Students enter as investigators examining a wartime disaster:
- 21 pilots killed due to defective airplane parts
- Two suspects: Joe Keller and Steve Deever
Each group receives:
- “Evidence” cards (quotes, summaries, character clues)
- A case file template
- Who is responsible?
- What evidence supports their claim?
“Today, you are not students—you are investigators. A tragedy has occurred, and your job is to determine responsibility. But be warned: in this case, truth is not simple.”
SESSION 2: CONTEXT + FIRST READING (ACT I)
Mini-Lesson
- Post–WWII America
- Rise of the American Dream
- Business ethics vs. patriotism
Assign roles:
- Discussion Leader
- Evidence Finder
- Connector (real-world links)
- Theme Tracker
- What is the Keller family hiding?
- How does denial shape Kate’s behavior?
- What tensions exist between Chris and Joe?
“Is Joe Keller a good man? Why or why not?”
SESSION 3: CHARACTER ON TRIAL (ACT II)
Experiential Activity: Mock Trial
Each group represents:
- Prosecution (Joe is guilty)
- Defense (Joe is justified)
- Jury (evaluates both)
Students use:
- Dialogue from Act I & II
- Character actions
- Logical reasoning
“You are about to decide whether Joe Keller is simply a father protecting his family—or a man responsible for the deaths of others.”
SESSION 4: REVEAL & MORAL COLLAPSE (ACT III)
Reading Focus
- Larry’s letter
- Joe’s realization
- Final tragedy
- Why does Joe say “they were all my sons”?
- What finally forces him to accept responsibility?
Joe’s actions reflect a failure to recognize responsibility beyond his family, leading to devastating consequences (SparkNotes).
SESSION 5: ETHICAL DEBATE – FAMILY VS. SOCIETY
Structured Debate
Prompt:
“Is a person’s first responsibility to their family or to society?”
Positions
- Side A: Family comes first
- Side B: Society comes first
Connect to:
- Corporate ethics
- Whistleblowers
- Modern business scandals
SESSION 6: WRITING WORKSHOP – ARGUMENT + SYNTHESIS
Writing Prompt Options
- To what extent is Joe Keller responsible for the deaths of the pilots?
- Does Chris represent moral integrity or hypocrisy?
- How does All My Sons critique the American Dream?
- Claim
- Evidence (textual)
- Commentary
- Counterargument
“Your job is not to retell the story—it is to make an argument about what the story means.”
SESSION 7: CREATIVE PERFORMANCE TASK
Option A: Scene Rewrites
Students rewrite a key scene:
- What if Joe confessed earlier?
- What if Larry survived?
Set the story in:
- A modern corporation
- A military contractor scandal
- A tech company
Groups perform their revised scenes.
SESSION 8: SOCRATIC SEMINAR
Discussion Questions
- Is Joe Keller a villain or a tragic figure?
- What does the play suggest about success in America?
- Can guilt ever be fully resolved?
- Speaker
- Evidence Tracker
- Questioner
- Synthesizer
SESSION 9: FINAL PERFORMANCE TASK – “ALL MY SONS” PROJECT
Group Project Options
Option 1: Documentary
- Explain the case
- Include “interviews” with characters
- Present moral conclusions
- Discuss responsibility and ethics
- Include textual evidence
- Images + quotes + explanations
- Focus on one major theme
ASSESSMENT
Formative
- Quick writes
- Discussion participation
- Trial performance
- Argumentative essay
- Group project
- Seminar participation
RUBRIC (Simplified)
Reading & Analysis
- Strong textual evidence
- Clear understanding of themes
- Active participation
- Meaningful contributions
- Clear claim
- Well-developed reasoning
- Use of evidence
OPTIONAL EXTENSIONS
- Compare to modern corporate scandals
- Connect to other Miller works (e.g., The Crucible)
- Research real WWII industrial ethics cases
TEACHER NOTES
- Emphasize moral ambiguity—there is no easy answer
- Encourage student voice in debate
- Use performance to deepen comprehension